The Undoing or Rabbit Hole?

[zazzsquad]

Hello!

Was wondering which of these two pieces of content do you prefer?

They're both critically acclaimed and feature Kidman in a starring role, but if you had to choose only one, which would you go with?

Here's how the critics and audiences feel about these projects:

The Undoing:

77% RT
7.6 IMDB
64 Metacritic

Rabbit Hole:

87% RT
7.0 IMDB
76 Metacritic


My vote: as much as I like Rabbit Hole and appreciate the Oscar nomination, I feel like The Undoing was just a bit more entertaining and memorable. I couldn't wait to see how the mystery unfolds and I loved seeing the tweets and memes from all over. It was an event viewing. What's more, I felt like the cinematography, costumes and set design were a bit more memorable or, rather, cinematic. With 6 hours of running time, I have to give The Undoing props too for the consistency and the effort of everyone involved, shooting over several months, and on location in New York. So, I think I'd go with The Undoing, flaws and all. I'm sensing I'll be in the minority though.

I look forward to your votes

[triflo]

Rabbit Hole all the way! My number 5 from Nicole top5 performances:)

[zazzsquad]

Dec 10, 2020 11:23:01 GMT triflo said:

Rabbit Hole all the way! My number 5 from Nicole top5 performances:)

Great! What are the other 4?

[guyinthevalley]

Rabbit Hole!!

[triflo]

Dec 10, 2020 11:45:06 GMT zazzsquad said:

Dec 10, 2020 11:23:01 GMT triflo said:

Rabbit Hole all the way! My number 5 from Nicole top5 performances:)

Great! What are the other 4?

1.Moulin Rouge! 2.Dogville 3.Birth 4.Portrait of a Lady 5.Rabbit Hole How does Your top5 look like?

[kaushik]

Having seen both: considering genre specifically, can't really compare - both are great performances

Rabbit Hole definitely ranks in my personal top 5: in order -- 1. Moulin Rouge 2. Big Little Lies 3. Dogville (I might be a minority, but loved this performance) 4. Rabbit Hole 5. Eyes Wide Shut, To Die For (a tie for me)

[zazzsquad]

Dec 10, 2020 12:24:13 GMT triflo said:

Dec 10, 2020 11:45:06 GMT zazzsquad said:

Great! What are the other 4?

1.Moulin Rouge! 2.Dogville 3.Birth 4.Portrait of a Lady 5.Rabbit Hole How does Your top5 look like?

Nice! Love Moulin Rouge and Dogville!

Uff, this is so hard

My favourite Nk performances are 1. Moulin Rouge! 2. Big Little Lies 3. The Hours, 4. To Die For and..... 5. Probably The Others

[Mr Dedlock]

I think it'll be very difficult for the undoing to win here, because Kidman's performance although Displaying full star power however her performance was more muted on purpose to keep the mystery going.

However In Rabbit Hole we get both an amazing performance along with Kidman's star appeal.

[perro del hortelano]

Rabbit Hole and it is not even close.

[zazzsquad]

Dec 10, 2020 15:50:48 GMT Mr Dedlock said:

I think it'll be very difficult for the undoing to win here, because Kidman's performance although Displaying full star power however her performance was more muted on purpose to keep the mystery going.

However In Rabbit Hole we get both an amazing performance along with Kidman's star appeal.

Her performance in RH was so much better. I’m totally with you. The Undoing was more of a Grace Kelly role — pretty, fashionable woman in distress.

The poll was for the film as a whole or the series as a whole. Which would you keep or and which you’d strike from her filmogrpahy if you had to. I guess I didn’t phrase the question correctly.